Rating  - A decidedly mixed review
This is an important, thoughtful, well-written book that I didn't really like very much. On the one hand, it analyzes the current political/economic situation in the US and argues very convincingly that it parallels the situations that other world-dominating powers (i.e., the Roman Empire, the British Empire, Hapsburg Spain, and the Dutch Republic) faced at the ends of their periods of influence. The comparisons focus on the ways that all of those empires-- and the modern US-- found their societies polarizing, the ways that religious fervor began to influence the governments, the decay of science in the face of faith, rapidly growing national debts, and, most of all, an overweening sense of exceptionalism, which led those empires to become aggressively ignorant about what had happened before them, since they believed that they were not only unique in history, but favored by God.
Doing all of this in a single book sounds like too much, and it is. That's why I didn't really care for the book. It's also why I found reading it something of a chore; the reader has to provide a lot of the work needed to connect the dots.
However, there's another reason this is an important book. In 1970, the author wrote The Emerging Republican Majority, which correctly predicted and described the current ascendancy of conservative Republicanism in the US. In many ways, he is literally one of the midwives of the Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Bush I, and Bush II administrations. Phillips now finds himself in what must be a very uncomfortable position: The strategy he created has spun wildly out of control, producing what is in his view literally a theocratic political party, the first such in US history. Further, he believes that the consequences of this will be potentially fatal to the republic.
By trying to do too much in a single volume, Phillips risks oversimplifying the issues, and at times, he takes rhetorical shortcuts in his arguments. However, his essential theme that the theocratic politicians currently in power have set us on a course that may doom the nation in the same way as earlier empires were doomed is well-supported.
So, I see this book as important, but reading it frustrated me in a number of ways.
Rating - American Theocracy - Compelling
Americans should take note. Though in a few places the book seems jumbled and difficult to get through, all in all it's convincing and backed up with solid footnotes. What do radical christianity, unchecked debt to asian countries and oil have in common? Check it out.
Rating  - A masterful work by Kevin Phillips
In American Theocracy, Phillips examines valid points relating to the influence of religion, debt and oil on our political process. I found the book interesting and the concepts enlightening. However, the book soon becomes redundant, stating the same points, with some minor differences, over and over again. Perhaps the abridged version of this book would be better, but my reading of the unabridged version seemed to last much longer than it should have. However, the concepts were informative and useful in understanding current political events.
Rating - An outsider's view
If the details of the arguments of this work are not always persuasive the author nevertheless achieves his stated purpose: to demolish any illusion among his fellow Americans that the US is in any way "exceptional" in its place and role in the world. Rather, he argues that it is rapidly following in the wake of the demise of past imperial powers Spain, Holland and Britain. The extraordinary rise and influence of extremist religious tendencies; the financialization and extreme indebtedness of the economy as "real wealth production" is outsourced; and the inevitable decline and gradual replacement of the economy's main fuel resource, are the three main streams that Phillips sees as once having broken their banks over previous leading imperial powers and that are now beginning to deluge the US.
I'm not an American but do have an interest in understanding the nature of the power that is so dominant in the political and cultural life of my country (Australia), in particular with a view to better understanding how one might best address issues that I see as detrimental to our society -- such as rising religious fundamentalism, the determination of many in power to follow the more extreme attitudes of the Bush administration re war, climate, human rights despite widely expressed public opinion to the contrary.
Perhaps for this reason I found first section of Phillip's book detailing oil's role for the US in comparison with the roles of other energy sources (coal, wind, timber) in past empires (Britian, Holland, Spain) painful with its baroque level of descriptive detail.
But I did find most absorbing his discussion of the historical roots and evolution of the Southern "character" (my term) and in particular of the Southernization of the North, or of the US as a whole. The role of the Southern Baptist Convention is especially enlightening. It helps me see the current Bush president -- the less educated persona, the disdain for science and progressive values, the born again (revived) Christian, filled with sense of being besieged, responding with arrogance and aggression, imbued especially with a sense of exceptionalism, of a unique mission to play out in the world -- as a fulfilment of the final rise of The South after the "divine chastening in righteousness" of the Civil War and Reconstruction period. This gives an interesting perspective to think about after having read Lieven's America Right or Wrong (my review on this is yet to come) which analysed many such nationalistic traits and attitudes to the rest of the world from a more "whole" US perspective.
Phillips then attempts to link the rise of religious fundamentalisms as a principle motive in foreign policy decisions but I felt he did little more than reinforce the what most take as a given (albeit with much added detail from regional election statistics) -- that the Bush administration has relied heavily on the religious fundamentalist vote. Although he discusses Middle East policy in the context of apocalyptic beliefs of Bush himself I remain sceptical: if Iraq were the proverbial world's supplier of broccoli rather than oil does anyone really think Bush's religious imagination would be so exercised in that region? Indeed, it is in this discussion that Phillips lets some of his otherwise love of detail desert him, and the reader finds in its place the old conservative biological and psychic metaphors commonly attached to "decline and fall" motifs: in place of hard supporting documentation one reads of a nation's "hubris", its "high-wire walks", its "youth and early middle age", its "animal spirits" and "vitality", the "lesser resilience" of its "clogged arteries" (p.311).
This is a book rich in illustrations of "decline" and I personally find any hint that the US power is on such a brink both disturbing and encouraging. Disturbing because one fears the potential for more irrational and bloody responses from the superpower in misguided efforts to delay the inevitable, encouraging because one seeks the eventual end of Anglo-Saxon imperial domination and power rivalries with related European nations these past 200 years with what must be one of the most bloody and genocidal periods of human history. The only real regret I have with American Theocracy is that while its author can see signs of "the end" of the current "empire", he apparently fails to see that the whole exercise from the beginning was one not of "greatness" but of arrogrance, greed and inhumanity.
Go to the Product Information page
page 10 of 10 5 6 7 8 9 10
Customer Reviews for Viking Adult,B00119O0M8,973.931 |
